• News
    • Africa
    • International
    • International News
    • Maghreb
    • Algeria
  • Politics
  • Business
    • International
    • Maghreb
    • Middle-East
    • Morocco
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Essays
    • Letters
    • Op-Eds
    • Voices
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Book and Movie Reviews
    • History
    • Profiles and interviews
    • Upcoming Events
  • Features
  • Diaspora
    • Events
    • Activities
    • Forums
    • Highlights
    • Africa
  • Education
  • Western Sahara
    • Autonomy plan
    • History
  • Sport
    • World Cup 2014
  • Videos
Search
  • About Us
  • Sitemap
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • Editorial Team
    • Contributors
    • Correspondents
    • Editorial Board
  • Privacy Policy
Morocco World News Morocco World News
  • News
    • UNGA Reiterates Support for Political Process to Solve Western Sahara Conflict
      Morocco

      UNGA Reiterates Support for Political Process to Solve Western Sahara Conflict

      Spain’s Iberia Airline to Launch Fez-Madrid Flight in 2020 Summer
      Economy

      Spain’s Iberia Airline to Launch Fez-Madrid Flight in Summer 2020

      Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World
      Casablanca

      Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World

      Saudi Arabia Applauds Morocco’s Efforts to Defend Palestinian Cause
      Morocco

      Saudi Arabia Applauds Morocco’s Efforts to Defend Palestinian Cause

      International Climate Action Observatory Showcases Two Moroccan Projects
      Economy

      International Climate Action Observatory Showcases Two Moroccan Projects

      AllAfricaInternationalInternational NewsMaghrebAlgeria
  • Politics
    • Saudi Arabia Applauds Morocco’s Efforts to Defend Palestinian Cause
      Morocco

      Saudi Arabia Applauds Morocco’s Efforts to Defend Palestinian Cause

      Abdelmadjid Tebboune Wins Algeria’s Presidential Election
      Africa

      Abdelmadjid Tebboune Wins Algeria’s Presidential Election

      Policy Center for the New South Launches 8th Atlantic Dialogues
      Africa

      Morocco’s New South Policy Center Launches 8th Atlantic Dialogues

      Former Moroccan PM Calls for ‘Historic Reconciliation’ with Algeria
      Morocco

      Former Moroccan PM Calls for ‘Historic Reconciliation’ with Algeria

      Algerians Boycott Vote, Clash With Police During Protests
      Algeria

      Algerians Boycott Vote, Clash With Police During Protests

  • Business
    • Spain’s Iberia Airline to Launch Fez-Madrid Flight in 2020 Summer
      Economy

      Spain’s Iberia Airline to Launch Fez-Madrid Flight in Summer 2020

      International Climate Action Observatory Showcases Two Moroccan Projects
      Economy

      International Climate Action Observatory Showcases Two Moroccan Projects

      Morocco’s OCP Joins World Business Council for Sustainable Development  
      Economy

      OCP, Ghana Launch Soil Fertility Map Development Project

      World Bank Loans Morocco $275 Million for Disaster Management Program
      Economy

      World Bank Loans Morocco $275 Million for Disaster Management Program

      Spanish Retailer Mango Seeks Comeback to Morocco
      Economy

      Spanish Retailer Mango Seeks Comeback to Morocco

      AllInternationalMaghrebMiddle-EastMorocco
  • Opinion
    • Ending the Moroccan Culture of ‘Criticism for Criticism’s Sake’
      Op-ed

      Ending the Moroccan Culture of ‘Criticism for Criticism’s Sake’

      Deal of the Century – Implications for Jordanian Identity and Sovereignty    
      Morocco

      Deal of the Century – Implications for Jordanian Identity and Sovereignty    

      Op-ed

      The Two Opposed Destinies of Morocco and Algeria

      Attacks on Mezouar Highlight Flaws in Morocco’s Diplomacy Toward Algeria
      Op-ed

      Attacks on Mezouar Highlight Flaws in Morocco’s Diplomacy Toward Algeria

      Vox’s Rhetoric on Ceuta, Melilla, and Morocco Will Eventually Backfire
      Op-ed

      Vox’s Rhetoric on Ceuta, Melilla and Morocco Will Eventually Backfire

      AllEditorialsEssaysLettersOp-EdsVoices
  • Lifestyle
    • Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World
      Casablanca

      Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World

      Moroccan-Egyptian Model Steals the Show Moschino Pre-Fall Catwalk
      Culture

      Moroccan-Egyptian Model Steals the Show at Moschino Pre-Fall Catwalk

      Fez to Host 1st National Pottery and Handcrafted Zellij on December 20
      Culture

      Fez to Host 1st National Pottery and Handcrafted Zellij Fair on December 20

      Princess Lalla Khadija Chairs Inauguration of Vivarium at Rabat’s Zoological Park
      Culture

      Princess Lalla Khadija Chairs Inauguration of Vivarium at Rabat’s Zoological Park

      UNESCO Lists Moroccan Gnawa as Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity
      Culture

      UNESCO Lists Moroccan Gnawa as Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity

      AllCultureBook and Movie ReviewsHistoryProfiles and interviewsUpcoming Events
  • Features
    • Gonzalez, the team, and the students
      Features

      Expression Through Art: Rabat Students Paint their Feelings 

      13 Photos to Move Morocco’s Chefchaouen to the Top of Your Bucket List
      Features

      12 Photos to Move Morocco’s Chefchaouen to the Top of Your Bucket List

      Taught to Go Back ‘Home’? A School for Moroccan Children in Amsterdam
      Features

      Taught to Go Back ‘Home’? A School for Moroccan Children in Amsterdam

      Economy

      Morocco’s ‘Passive’ Tourist Industry Does Not Cater to Chinese Visitors

      Diaspora

      ‘Rely on Your Instincts’: Scientist Kamal Oudrhiri at Moonshot Morocco

  • Diaspora
    • National Assembly of Quebec Honors Two Moroccan Deputies
      Diaspora

      National Assembly of Quebec Honors Two Moroccan Deputies

      Diaspora

      One Airline ‘Very Interested’ in Opening Murcia-Morocco Direct Flight

      Jihane Makhzoumi
      Diaspora

      French Court Charges Moroccan Woman with Terrorism, Kidnapping Minors

      Diaspora

      Moroccan Football Star Achraf Hakimi: I Never Experienced Racist Insults

      Diaspora

      Spain Imprisons Moroccan-Spanish Maker of ISIS Uniforms

      AllEventsActivitiesForumsHighlightsAfrica
  • Education
    • Moroccan Teachers Continue Strikes Over Promotion Policy
      Education

      Moroccan Teachers Continue Strikes Over Promotion Policy

      Education

      How Concern Can Lead to Professional Development

      NGO Aspires to Promote Nuclear Sciences to Moroccan Women
      Education

      NGO Aspires to Promote Nuclear Sciences to Moroccan Women

      Morocco to Host Conference on Preventing Extremism Through Religion
      Education

      Morocco to Host Conference on Preventing Extremism Through Religion

      Primary School Near Tangier to Pilot Mandarin Chinese Classes
      Education

      Primary School Near Tangier to Pilot Mandarin Chinese Classes

  • Western Sahara
    • UNGA Reiterates Support for Political Process to Solve Western Sahara Conflict
      Morocco

      UNGA Reiterates Support for Political Process to Solve Western Sahara Conflict

      Morocco

      Gambia to Open Consulate in Morocco’s Dakhla

      Turkish FM, Turkey Supports Morocco’s Territorial Integrity, Stability
      Morocco

      Turkish FM: Turkey Supports Morocco’s Territorial Integrity, Stability

      Jamaica Reiterates Decision to Withdraw Recognition of Self-Proclaimed 'SADR'
      Highlights on Morocco

      Jamaica Reiterates Decision to Withdraw Recognition of Self-Proclaimed ‘SADR’

      Lesotho Says Any Previous Statements in Favor of Polisario Are ‘Void’
      Highlights on Morocco

      Lesotho Says Any Previous Statements in Favor of Polisario Are ‘Void’

      AllAutonomy planHistory
  • Sport
    • Morocco’s Mohsin Attaf Earns Gold at Borneo Open Judo Championship
      Highlights on Morocco

      Morocco’s Mohsin Attaf Earns Gold at Borneo Open Judo Championship

      King Mohammed VI Inaugurates Renovated Football Center Near Rabat
      Morocco

      King Mohammed VI Inaugurates Renovated Football Center Near Rabat

      Undocumented Moroccan Migrant to Compete in Spanish Taekwondo Competition
      Morocco

      Undocumented Moroccan Migrant to Compete in Spanish Taekwondo Competition

      CAF Awards 2019 Shortlist Names Two Moroccan Football Players
      Morocco

      CAF Awards 2019 Shortlist Names Two Moroccan Football Players

      Fez to Host 5th International Marathon on January 12
      Morocco

      Fez to Host 5th International Marathon on January 12

      AllWorld Cup 2014
  • Videos
    • Everyday Life Coldplayvideo
      Lifestyle

      Coldplay’s “Everyday Life” Music Video Features Morocco

      Video: Morocco’s Ouzoud Falls Overflow After Heavy Rainfall
      Morocco

      Video: Morocco’s Ouzoud Falls Overflow After Heavy Rainfall

      Video, American Woman Cries After Raja Casablanca Tickets Sell Outvideo
      Morocco

      Video: American Woman Weeps After Raja Casablanca Tickets Sell Out

      Video: City of Amsterdam Hears Call to Prayer for the First Time
      International News

      Video: City of Amsterdam Hears Call to Prayer for the First Time

      Video: Midelt Residents Flee as Second Earthquake Shocks Central Morocco
      Morocco

      Video: Midelt Residents Flee as Second Earthquake Shocks Central Morocco

  • Home
  • Food
    • Morocco to Bring Local Products to Middle East International Food Show
      Culture

      Morocco to Bring Local Products to Middle East International Food Show

      How to Make Qrashel, Moroccan Sesame Rolls
      Food

      How to Make Qrashel, Moroccan Sesame Rolls

      How to Make Harsha, Moroccan Semolina Bread
      Food

      How to Make Harsha, Moroccan Semolina Bread

      How to Make Chebakia
      Food

      How to Make Chebakia

      How to Make Moroccan Sellou
      Food

      How to Make Moroccan Sellou

      AllHealth and DietRecipesRestaurant Reviews
  • Travel
    • Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World
      Casablanca

      Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World

      13 Photos to Move Morocco’s Chefchaouen to the Top of Your Bucket List
      Features

      12 Photos to Move Morocco’s Chefchaouen to the Top of Your Bucket List

      Economy

      Morocco’s High-Speed Train on Track for 3 Million Passengers in 2019

      10 Photos to Inspire a Winter Trek of Morocco’s Mount Toubkal
      Lifestyle

      10 Photos to Inspire a Winter Trek of Morocco’s Mount Toubkal

      Horse-Drawn Carriage Drivers in Marrakech Debut Winter Uniforms
      Culture

      Horse-Drawn Carriage Drivers in Marrakech Debut Winter Uniforms

      AllExperiencesHotel ReviewsWhere to visit
  • Culture
    • Moroccan-Egyptian Model Steals the Show Moschino Pre-Fall Catwalk
      Culture

      Moroccan-Egyptian Model Steals the Show at Moschino Pre-Fall Catwalk

      Fez to Host 1st National Pottery and Handcrafted Zellij on December 20
      Culture

      Fez to Host 1st National Pottery and Handcrafted Zellij Fair on December 20

      Princess Lalla Khadija Chairs Inauguration of Vivarium at Rabat’s Zoological Park
      Culture

      Princess Lalla Khadija Chairs Inauguration of Vivarium at Rabat’s Zoological Park

      UNESCO Lists Moroccan Gnawa as Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity
      Culture

      UNESCO Lists Moroccan Gnawa as Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity

      Muhammad, Aliyah Among Top 10 Most Popular Baby Names in US
      Culture

      Muhammad, Aaliyah Among Top 10 Most Popular Baby Names in US

      AllBook and Movie ReviewsHistoryProfiles and interviewsUpcoming Events
  • Style
    • The Weeknd Flashes ‘I Love Morocco’ Jacket in New York
      Lifestyle

      The Weeknd Flashes ‘I Love Morocco’ Jacket in New York

      Moroccan Models Grace Vogue Arabia Cover: “Arab Girls Rock!”
      Lifestyle

      Moroccan Models Grace Vogue Arabia Cover: “Arab Girls Rock!”

      Nora Sahraoui Brings Moroccan Fashion to Miami Modest Fashion Week
      Fashion

      Nora Sahraoui Brings Moroccan Fashion to Miami Modest Fashion Week

      Morocco World News Wears: Picard Leather Goods
      Lifestyle

      Morocco World News Wears: Picard Leather Goods

      Morocco Mall: Coming Soon to Rabat, Marrakech
      Economy

      Morocco Mall: Coming Soon to Rabat, Marrakech

      AllFashionInterior DesignShopping
  • Places
    • Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World
      Casablanca

      Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World

      13 Photos to Move Morocco’s Chefchaouen to the Top of Your Bucket List
      Features

      12 Photos to Move Morocco’s Chefchaouen to the Top of Your Bucket List

      Everything You Need to Know About the 2019 Marrakech Film Festival
      Cinema

      Everything You Need to Know About the 2019 Marrakech Film Festival

      Enjoy an Enchanting Evening in Rabat with the Welsh National Opera
      Culture

      Enjoy an Enchanting Evening in Rabat with the Welsh National Opera

      Explore Morocco’s Postal History at Barid Al-Maghrib Museum in Rabat
      Culture

      Explore Morocco’s Postal History at Bank Al-Maghrib Museum in Rabat

      AllCasablancaFezMarrakechRabat
  • Highlights
  • Events
  • Moroccans of the world
  • Media
  • Services
     
Home Opinion Why I reject Morocco’s new constitution

Why I reject Morocco’s new constitution

Guardian

Morocco World News
By
Morocco World News
-
Jun 23, 2011

Guardian

June 23, 2011

The people have not been consulted and the government is still subject to the king’s whim. This is not a ‘reformed’ constitution

While bringing some improvements, Morocco’s proposed new constitution takes us back to the same institutional structure for the country. It matches neither Moroccans’ aspirations nor the new regional context.

Reform of the constitution has been conducted in an anti-democratic manner, quite unlike what the king, Mohammed VI, claimed in his speech on 17 June. The ad hoc commission tasked with preparing the new constitution was appointed by the king and composed almost entirely of men and women whose loyalty was to him.

The palace, deaf and blind, chose to royally ignore the wave of contestation that pushed him to reform and leaned on an aging and subservient political class, which in any case had never asked for change.

It ignored the protests of the 20 February movement, which rejected this imposed process and considered that the conditions necessary for the drafting of a democratic constitution were not met. Self-assured and arrogant, the regime stubbornly continued in this vein.

This “consultative” approach turned into a farce when the commission refused to allow the heads of political parties to see the draft constitution, finally allowing them only 24 hours to prepare their remarks. This reform has been concocted in secrecy, without real concessions, and under the strict supervision of the king’s political counsellor. These are the facts.

The palace followed this approach to its logical conclusion. At the end of the exercise, we were presented with a fait accompli, particularly as the new constitution is being put up for a referendum as a whole and not on a per-article basis. The result is therefore disappointing.

It must be acknowledged that the draft presented by the king includes some improvements. The preamble of the constitution, lyrical and replete with homilies, recognises for the first time the diversity – of culture and heritage – of Moroccan society. Amazigh is recognised as an official language, answering a historic demand of the regions of the north. The constitution guarantees in its text a number of rights and freedoms, starting with the right to life and freedom of speech. One cannot but think that the current constitution already guarantees such rights, without really implementing them.

But where we most keenly expected change, the constitution disappoints most severely. With regard to the draft, I had planned to judge on only one criterion: the creation of a parliamentary monarchy and the limitation of the king’s powers, since I considered the other improvements as born out of common sense and self-evident.

For me, it’s clear: we were under a powerful monarchy in which the king was the head of the executive, and we will remain under the same system with some superficial changes.

In the new draft constitution, the king still appoints the prime minister (Art 46, on the condition that he is a member of the party with the largest score in parliamentary elections), appoints ministers based on recommendations by the prime minister (Art 47), can dismiss ministers (Art 47) and probably the government (Art 47, which leaves it unclear where the king can dismiss the prime minister, entailing a dissolution of the cabinet).

He heads the council of ministers (Art 48, although he can now delegate this function to his liking on specific occasions) and is therefore still the head of the executive branch of government. He is the commander of the armed forces (Art 53), appoints military personnel and can delegate this function (Art 53), approves civil service nominations via his presidency of the council of ministers (Art 48), appoints and accredits ambassadors (Art 55), signs and ratifies international treaties (Art 55, with conditions). He addresses parliament still with no right of reply (Art 52), presides over the October opening session of parliament (Art 65), and can dissolve the chambers of parliament (Art 51). He approves the nomination of judges (Art 57), can grant pardons (Art 58), presides over the Higher Council of the Judiciary (Art 56), the National Security Council (Art 54) and can declare a state of emergency (Art 59).

To summarise, even when he does not keep his current prerogatives, the king retains power over the head of government as he must give his direct or indirect consent over all decisions through his presidency of the council of ministers and the National Security Council. Not a single government decision can be promulgated with the king’s approval, and when he may delegate his powers this remains entirely according to his whim.

Because of this, he remains directly and indirectly, for all intents and purpose, the head of government and retains the first and last word with regards to public policies and the state’s direction. We can even wonder what is the point of nominating a head of government from the largest party in parliament, whatever its political ideology, when he must have the consent of the king in his policy. We are far from a parliamentary monarchy and more or less in the same configuration of an executive monarch without whom nothing can be decided. And they call this progress!

My personal national duty is to reject this constitution because it leads us to an identical institutional infrastructure for the country, one in which the king still both reigns and governs. It is to reject because it does not bring the deep renewal that could bring real change to the country’s political practice and because universal suffrage will continue to have little impact on the country’s governance. It is to reject it because it does not meet my hope of seeing the creation of a parliamentary monarchy. My national duty is to reject a reform that, the day after the referendum, will leave Morocco facing the same problems of absolutism and arbitrary rule.

• This is a shortened version of the article, which was originally published in French

Facebook
Twitter
Google+
Linkedin
WhatsApp
Pinterest
    Morocco World News

    RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

    UNGA Reiterates Support for Political Process to Solve Western Sahara Conflict
    Morocco

    UNGA Reiterates Support for Political Process to Solve Western Sahara Conflict

    Spain’s Iberia Airline to Launch Fez-Madrid Flight in 2020 Summer
    Economy

    Spain’s Iberia Airline to Launch Fez-Madrid Flight in Summer 2020

    Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World
    Casablanca

    Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World

    Saudi Arabia Applauds Morocco’s Efforts to Defend Palestinian Cause
    Morocco

    Saudi Arabia Applauds Morocco’s Efforts to Defend Palestinian Cause

    International Climate Action Observatory Showcases Two Moroccan Projects
    Economy

    International Climate Action Observatory Showcases Two Moroccan Projects

    Moroccan-Egyptian Model Steals the Show Moschino Pre-Fall Catwalk
    Culture

    Moroccan-Egyptian Model Steals the Show at Moschino Pre-Fall Catwalk

    MOST WATCHED VIDEOS
    Everyday Life Coldplayvideo

    Coldplay’s “Everyday Life” Music Video Features Morocco

    Morocco World News - Dec 11, 2019
    Video: Morocco’s Ouzoud Falls Overflow After Heavy Rainfall

    Video: Morocco’s Ouzoud Falls Overflow After Heavy Rainfall

    Morocco Dec 6, 2019
    Video, American Woman Cries After Raja Casablanca Tickets Sell Outvideo

    Video: American Woman Weeps After Raja Casablanca Tickets Sell Out

    Morocco Nov 29, 2019
    Video: City of Amsterdam Hears Call to Prayer for the First Time

    Video: City of Amsterdam Hears Call to Prayer for the First Time

    International News Nov 28, 2019
    Video: Midelt Residents Flee as Second Earthquake Shocks Central Morocco

    Video: Midelt Residents Flee as Second Earthquake Shocks Central Morocco

    Morocco Nov 18, 2019
    MOST READ

    Sorry. No data so far.

    LIFESTYLE UPDATES

    Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World
    Casablanca Dec 13, 2019

    Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World

    Moroccan-Egyptian Model Steals the Show Moschino Pre-Fall Catwalk
    Culture Dec 13, 2019

    Moroccan-Egyptian Model Steals the Show at Moschino Pre-Fall Catwalk

    Fez to Host 1st National Pottery and Handcrafted Zellij on December 20
    Culture Dec 13, 2019

    Fez to Host 1st National Pottery and Handcrafted Zellij Fair on...

    EXPERIENCES

    • Experiences Disney Adds New Morocco-Inspired Attractions to EPCOT Theme Park Disney Adds New Morocco-Inspired Attractions to EPCOT Theme Park
    • Experiences Olives, Dates, and Pomegranates: Daily Life in Morocco’s Skoura Oasis Olives, Dates, and Pomegranates: Daily Life in Morocco’s Skoura Oasis
    • Experiences Hiking the Mgoun Summit, Morocco’s Third Highest Peak Hiking the Mgoun Summit, Morocco’s Third Highest Peak

    MOST READ

    MOST READ OPINIONS
    • Vox’s Rhetoric on Ceuta, Melilla, and Morocco Will Eventually Backfire Vox’s Rhetoric on Ceuta, Melilla and Morocco Will Eventually Backfire 866 views
    • The Two Opposed Destinies of Morocco and Algeria 673 views
    • Attacks on Mezouar Highlight Flaws in Morocco’s Diplomacy Toward Algeria Attacks on Mezouar Highlight Flaws in Morocco’s Diplomacy Toward Algeria 384 views
    • Deal of the Century – Implications for Jordanian Identity and Sovereignty     Deal of the Century – Implications for Jordanian Identity and Sovereignty     193 views
    • Ending the Moroccan Culture of ‘Criticism for Criticism’s Sake’ Ending the Moroccan Culture of ‘Criticism for Criticism’s Sake’ 67 views

    Latest Articles

    UNGA Reiterates Support for Political Process to Solve Western Sahara Conflict

    Spain’s Iberia Airline to Launch Fez-Madrid Flight in Summer 2020

    Casablanca Among Top 50 Friendliest Cities in the World

    Saudi Arabia Applauds Morocco’s Efforts to Defend Palestinian Cause

    International Climate Action Observatory Showcases Two Moroccan Projects

    Newsletter

    Invalid email address
    You can unsubscribe at any time.
    Thanks for subscribing! Please check your email for further instructions.
    Morocco World News

    About us

    Morocco World News: Championing Free Speech and Thoughtful Debate Through Journalistic Excellence.

    Morocco World News is dedicated to bringing the news of Morocco and the MENA region to a wide audience without bias or a political agenda.

    Contact us: [email protected]

    Useful Links

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Correspondents
    • Editorial Board
    Edit with Live CSS
    Save
    Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete.

    Sign up to the best of our news, informed analysis and opinions on what matters to you.

    Invalid email address
    You can unsubscribe at any time.
    Thanks for subscribing! Please check your email for further instructions.