• Home
  • News
    • Africa
    • International
    • International News
    • Maghreb
    • Algeria
  • Politics
  • Business
    • International
    • Maghreb
    • Middle-East
    • Morocco
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Essays
    • Letters
    • Op-Eds
    • Voices
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Book and Movie Reviews
    • History
    • Profiles and interviews
    • Upcoming Events
  • Features
  • Society
    • Expatriates
    • Gender issues
    • Portraits
    • Ramadan
    • Religion
  • Education
  • Covid-19
  • Western Sahara
    • Autonomy plan
    • History
Search
  • About Us
  • Sitemap
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • Editorial Team
    • Contributors
    • Correspondents
    • Editorial Board
Morocco World News Morocco World News
  • Home
  • News
    • Chile Supports Morocco’s Autonomy Plan
      Highlights on Morocco

      Chile Supports Morocco’s Autonomy Plan

      David Fisher Biden Will Build on Trump’s Western Sahara Breakthrough
      Morocco

      David Fischer: Biden Will Build on Trump’s Western Sahara Breakthrough

      Chief Rabbi Pinto Opens 1st Jewish Kindergarten in Morocco
      Morocco

      Chief Rabbi Pinto Opens 1st Jewish Kindergarten in Morocco

      Economy

      Samir Bennis: Morocco Needs to End Language Barriers to Attract Investments

      Algeria to Repatriate Trapped Algerian Students From Morocco After Backlash
      Highlights on Morocco

      Algeria to Repatriate Trapped Algerian Students From Morocco After Backlash

      AllAfricaInternationalInternational NewsMaghrebAlgeria
  • Politics
    • David Fisher Biden Will Build on Trump’s Western Sahara Breakthrough
      Morocco

      David Fischer: Biden Will Build on Trump’s Western Sahara Breakthrough

      Morocco Ranks 53rd in 2021 Military Strength Report, Climbs 3 Spots
      Morocco

      Morocco Ranks 53rd in 2021 Military Strength Report, Climbs 3 Spots

      Visit of King Mohammed VI to Israel Depends on Re-Launch of Israeli-Palestinian Negotiations
      Morocco

      Visit of King Mohammed VI to Israel Depends on Re-Launch of Israeli-Palestinian Negotiations

      France Cracks Down on ‘Islamist Separatism,’ Shuts Down 9 Mosques
      International

      France Cracks Down on ‘Islamist Separatism,’ Shuts Down 9 Mosques

      Omar Hilale: Jewish Culture Is Integral to Morocco’s DNA, History
      International

      Omar Hilale: Jewish Culture Is Integral to Morocco’s DNA, History

  • Business
    • Economy

      Samir Bennis: Morocco Needs to End Language Barriers to Attract Investments

      Oxfam Morocco Needs New Tax System to Reduce Social Inequalities
      Morocco

      Oxfam: Morocco Needs New Tax System to Reduce Social Inequalities

      Minister Rabbah Dakhla - is an International Hub for Energy Investment.
      Africa

      Minister Rabbah: Dakhla is an International Hub for Energy Investments

      Morocco’s Agricultural Production to Increase in 2021
      Economy

      Morocco’s Agricultural Production to Increase in 2021

      Morocco's Dirham Appreciates by 0.5% Against Euro
      Economy

      Morocco’s Dirham Appreciates by 0.5% Against Euro

      AllInternationalMaghrebMiddle-EastMorocco
  • Opinion
    • Amazigh Identity and Morocco’s Multicultural Challenge
      Culture

      Amazigh Identity and Morocco’s Multicultural Challenge

      The US-Morocco-Israel Agreement and the Triumph of Pragmatism
      Opinion

      The US-Morocco-Israel Agreement and the Triumph of Pragmatism

      Casablanca Floods Unearth Shocking Lack of Accountability
      Editorials

      Casablanca Floods Unearth Shocking Lack of Accountability

      Op-ed

      Historical and Legal Bases of Morocco’s Sovereignty over Western Sahara

      Op-ed

      How UN Language on Western Sahara Creates a Point of No Return

      AllEditorialsEssaysLettersOp-EdsVoices
  • Lifestyle
    • Documentaries’ allure lies in narratives of unfiltered real events that might reveal shocking and unsettling truths.
      Book and Movie Reviews

      Six Shocking and Unsettling Documentaries You Must Watch

      “Reflet” Exhibition Promoting Art in Morocco Amid COVID-19
      Casablanca

      “Reflet” Exhibition Promoting Art in Morocco Amid COVID-19

      Amazigh Identity and Morocco’s Multicultural Challenge
      Culture

      Amazigh Identity and Morocco’s Multicultural Challenge

      Eleven of the Best Moroccan Podcasts Everyone Should Follow
      Book and Movie Reviews

      Eleven of the Best Moroccan Podcasts Everyone Should Follow

      Moroccan Visual Artist MACHIMA’s Mural Art in Morocco’s Cities
      Culture

      Moroccan Visual Artist MACHIMA’s Mural Art in Morocco’s Cities

      AllCultureBook and Movie ReviewsHistoryProfiles and interviewsUpcoming Events
  • Features
    • Documentaries’ allure lies in narratives of unfiltered real events that might reveal shocking and unsettling truths.
      Book and Movie Reviews

      Six Shocking and Unsettling Documentaries You Must Watch

      Eleven of the Best Moroccan Podcasts Everyone Should Follow
      Book and Movie Reviews

      Eleven of the Best Moroccan Podcasts Everyone Should Follow

      Moroccan Visual Artist MACHIMA’s Mural Art in Morocco’s Cities
      Culture

      Moroccan Visual Artist MACHIMA’s Mural Art in Morocco’s Cities

      Revenge Porn Case Shows Morality Laws Are Mission Impossible
      Features

      Revenge Porn Case Shows Morality Laws Are Mission Impossible

      Smart Ways to Make 2021 a Better Year Than 2020
      Culture

      Smart Ways to Make 2021 a Better Year Than 2020

  • Society
    • Chief Rabbi Pinto Opens 1st Jewish Kindergarten in Morocco
      Morocco

      Chief Rabbi Pinto Opens 1st Jewish Kindergarten in Morocco

      Algeria to Repatriate Trapped Algerian Students From Morocco After Backlash
      Highlights on Morocco

      Algeria to Repatriate Trapped Algerian Students From Morocco After Backlash

      Moroccan NGO to Collaborate With US Against Antisemitism, Anti-Zionism
      Morocco

      Moroccan NGO to Collaborate With US Against Antisemitism, Anti-Zionism

      Greece: Muslims Denounce Archbishop’s Insulting Remarks Against Islam
      International

      Greece: Muslims Denounce Archbishop’s Insulting Remarks Against Islam

      Morocco Arrests 4 Suspects for Human Trafficking
      Morocco

      Morocco Arrests 4 Suspects for Human Trafficking

      AllExpatriatesGender issuesPortraitsRamadanReligion
  • Education
    • Documentaries’ allure lies in narratives of unfiltered real events that might reveal shocking and unsettling truths.
      Book and Movie Reviews

      Six Shocking and Unsettling Documentaries You Must Watch

      COVID-19 Impacts Foreign Students Enrollment in Morocco
      Education

      COVID-19 Impacts Foreign Students Enrollment in Morocco

      Morocco's UM6P, MIT Launch Joint Program for Youth Entrepreneurship
      Education

      Morocco’s UM6P, MIT Launch Joint Program for Youth Entrepreneurship

      Seven useful languages you should learn
      Education

      Seven Useful Languages You Should Learn This Year

      Morocco to Cancel 109 Vocational Training Courses for Lack of Jobs
      Education

      Morocco to Cancel 109 Vocational Training Courses for Lack of Jobs

  • Covid-19
    • COVID-19 Morocco Records 806 New Cases
      Covid-19

      COVID-19: Morocco Records 806 New Cases

      Morocco Records 1,240 New COVID-19 Cases Out of 19,823 Tested
      Covid-19

      Morocco Records 1,240 New COVID-19 Cases Out of 19,823 Tested

      Number of Active COVID-19 Cases in Morocco Reaches 17,161
      Covid-19

      Number of Active COVID-19 Cases in Morocco Reaches 17,161

      Morocco to Receive 1st Lot of COVID-19 Vaccines Next Week
      Covid-19

      Morocco to Receive 1st Lot of COVID-19 Vaccines Next Week

      Spain Suspends PCR Test Requirement for Passengers from Morocco
      Covid-19

      Spain Suspends PCR Test Requirement for Passengers from Morocco

  • Western Sahara
    • Chile Supports Morocco’s Autonomy Plan
      Highlights on Morocco

      Chile Supports Morocco’s Autonomy Plan

      Qatar Stands With Morocco, Supports Autonomy Plan
      Western Sahara

      Qatar Stands With Morocco, Supports Autonomy Plan

      Bourita Urges Europe to Support Morocco’s Autonomy Plan
      Morocco

      Bourita Urges Europe to Support Morocco’s Autonomy Plan

      French MP: Morocco ‘Can Count on France’ on Western Sahara
      Western Sahara

      French MP: Morocco ‘Can Count on France’ on Western Sahara

      Forty Countries Join US, Morocco at Conference on Autonomy Plan
      Western Sahara

      Forty Countries Join US, Morocco at Conference on Autonomy Plan

      AllAutonomy planHistory
  • Home
  • Food
    • Casablanca’s Franklin Roosevelt Starbucks Among World’s ‘Most Beautiful’
      Food

      Casablanca’s Franklin Roosevelt Starbucks Among World’s ‘Most Beautiful’

      Cuisine

      Moroccan Chef Hamid Miss Celebrates Morocco’s Cuisine in France

      Cuisine

      Moroccan Cuisine: Nine Must-Visit Restaurants in Rabat

      Olive Oil in Morocco: Health Benefits of Moroccan Virgin Olive Oil
      Cuisine

      Morocco’s Organic Olive Oil: Health Benefits of Moroccan Virgin Olive Oil

      7 Best Restaurants in Casablanca
      Casablanca

      Where to Eat in Morocco: 7 Best Restaurants in Casablanca

      AllHealth and DietRecipesRestaurant Reviews
  • Travel
    • 5 Historical Mausoleums You Should Visit in Morocco
      Culture

      5 Historical Mausoleums You Should Visit in Morocco

      Morocco’s Red City: Touristic Places in Marrakech You Must Visit
      Culture

      Morocco’s Red City: Touristic Places in Marrakech You Must Visit

      Laayoune Airport: Air traffic down 51% at the end of November
      Morocco

      Laayoune Airport: Air traffic down 51% at the end of November

      Royal Air Maroc to Launch New Flights From Casablanca To Dubai
      Morocco

      Royal Air Maroc to Launch New Flights From Casablanca To Dubai

      he City of Ouarzazate, Morocco Africa’s Hollywood
      Cinema

      The City of Ouarzazate, Morocco: Africa’s Hollywood

      AllExperiencesHotel ReviewsWhere to visit
  • Culture
    • Documentaries’ allure lies in narratives of unfiltered real events that might reveal shocking and unsettling truths.
      Book and Movie Reviews

      Six Shocking and Unsettling Documentaries You Must Watch

      “Reflet” Exhibition Promoting Art in Morocco Amid COVID-19
      Casablanca

      “Reflet” Exhibition Promoting Art in Morocco Amid COVID-19

      Amazigh Identity and Morocco’s Multicultural Challenge
      Culture

      Amazigh Identity and Morocco’s Multicultural Challenge

      Eleven of the Best Moroccan Podcasts Everyone Should Follow
      Book and Movie Reviews

      Eleven of the Best Moroccan Podcasts Everyone Should Follow

      Moroccan Visual Artist MACHIMA’s Mural Art in Morocco’s Cities
      Culture

      Moroccan Visual Artist MACHIMA’s Mural Art in Morocco’s Cities

      AllBook and Movie ReviewsHistoryProfiles and interviewsUpcoming Events
  • Style
    • Smart Ways to Make 2021 a Better Year Than 2020
      Culture

      Smart Ways to Make 2021 a Better Year Than 2020

      Travel to Morocco: 6 Unique Moroccan Souvenirs
      Highlights on Morocco

      Travel to Morocco: 6 Unique Moroccan Souvenirs

      Hassan Hajjaj Somewhere Between Modernity and Tradition
      Culture

      Hassan Hajjaj: Somewhere Between Modernity and Tradition

      Designer Ghitta Laskrouif Sheds Light on Sustainable Fashion in Morocco
      Fashion

      Designer Ghitta Laskrouif Sheds Light on Sustainable Fashion in Morocco

      Adidas Adds Moroccan Tile Pattern to Iconic ‘Stan Smith’ Shoe
      Fashion

      Adidas Adds Moroccan Tile Pattern to Iconic ‘Stan Smith’ Shoe

      AllFashionInterior DesignShopping
  • Places
    • “Reflet” Exhibition Promoting Art in Morocco Amid COVID-19
      Casablanca

      “Reflet” Exhibition Promoting Art in Morocco Amid COVID-19

      Global Shapers Community Opens Hub in Morocco’s Laayoune
      Economy

      Global Shapers Community Opens Hub in Morocco’s Laayoune

      Casablanca Floods: Lydec Breaks Silence, Tries to Make Up
      Administrative

      Casablanca Floods: Lydec Breaks Silence, Tries to Make Up

      Collapsed Building in Casablanca Killed 3 Victims, Including 1 Child
      Casablanca

      Collapsed Building in Casablanca Killed 3 Victims, Including 1 Child

      Morocco’s Red City: Touristic Places in Marrakech You Must Visit
      Culture

      Morocco’s Red City: Touristic Places in Marrakech You Must Visit

      AllCasablancaFezMarrakechRabatTangier
  • Highlights
  • Events
  • Moroccans of the world
  • Media
  • Services
Home Opinion Arab Spring: R.I.P.?

Arab Spring: R.I.P.?

Dr. Josef Olmert

Staff Writer
By
Staff Writer
-
Jul 29, 2011
Spread the love

Dr. Josef Olmert

July 29, 2011

huffingtonpost

The Middle East summer is in full force, but not the “Arab Spring”. In some countries it is just a memory, in others it never showed up, and the domino effect of what started in Tunisia, with such big promise, has not materialized.

Egypt, Syria and Libya may be the exceptions, and judging by what is happening in the first two, we can learn a lot about the realities of the Arab world. Egypt and Syria were briefly united between 1958 and 1961, in what was the greatest victory ever of the cause of Pan-Arabism. It was a great victory, because there can be no other two countries that are so different from each other than Egypt and Syria. Pan-Arabism is long dead as a viable political doctrine, and also the conflicts with Israel have long failed to be the most solid cement of Arab politics.

The Islamic movement is surely potent and popular, but here too the differences and antagonisms prevent it from being the overall unifying force of the Arab world. Under these circumstances, it should come as no surprise that the anticipated big bang was not to be. Many of the issues which triggered the “Arab Spring” in the first place are clearly common throughout the Middle East, but many others are not.

Egypt and Syria present us with two models of the Arab state, as developed in the region in the post-colonial era, the “natural” and the “artificial” state. Egypt has been a distinct geopolitical entity for 5000 years, ruled by a strong central government, an institution of utmost importance in a country whose well-being has always depended on controlling the Nile river. There is no demographic issue, as the population is overwhelmingly Muslim with a small (10%) Christian minority. Egypt is a governable entity, and its modern political history has been relatively stable, with one major shift of power in 1952, with the “Free Officers” Revolution.

To be sure, there has been a debate about Egypt’s national identity, whether Egyptian or Arab, with the constant challenge of the Islamic forces — but never a question mark about the territorial integrity and internal solidarity. The “Tahrir revolution” was the most violent internal political change in Egypt’s modern history. But as we move away from the momentous events of January-March, it is becoming increasingly obvious that the old regime is still in place, though the Mubarak family is not. Hence the talk about a “second corrective revolution”, something that may very well remain an unfulfilled aspiration of the brave youths who brought Mubarak down. The Egyptian state proved stronger than the forces of radical change. There is a dominant center of power — the military — which is regarded as the people’s army, a viable sense of national unity and no sectarian division, which threatens internal cohesion.

Syria is almost the diametrical opposite of all that. Its current borders are artificial, created by the French colonial power. Maps of the Middle East prior to WWI have never shown a country with Syria’s current borders. No wonder, that the question of national and territorial identity has become the one single issue which has posed the greatest challenge to Syria’s domestic stability since independence in 1946. The Ba’ath regime has tried to deal with this issue, but in the absence of real political legitimacy, emanating from its clear non-Sunni sectarian character, it had to rely on the unrestricted use of violence as its modus operandi. Brutal repression enabled the regime to enforce a measure of stability for a relatively long period of time, but never made it more legitimate in the eyes of the population, the majority of which has continued to maintain and adhere to pre-Ba’ath loyalties, be them religious or regional.

This is the main difference between Egypt and Syria, the difference that explains the present and future political development of these two Arab countries. In Egypt, the ruling military council still enjoys a large measure of popular support, and in a slow, incremental way is leading the country towards elections, that may be much more representative than under Mubarak, though short of accepted western norms. In the process, the council allows the Muslim Brotherhood to participate in the political discourse, thus neutralizing whatever incentive they might have to resort to violence. The Brotherhood, as well as other political forces get something, not all they wish, but enough to keep them on working terms with the military.

Syria is a completely different story. The regime cannot engage in any real political dialogue with its rivals, as they do not accept its legitimacy. The military is also hated by most of the people, and there are no viable, effective civic organizations that can bridge the gaps between the various sectarian groups. So, unlike Egypt, Syria is on course to more violence, collapse of central authority and possible break-up along sectarian lines.

One “Arab spring”? Not really…

 

Photo credit: sheet.com

Facebook
Twitter
Linkedin
WhatsApp
Email
ReddIt
Pinterest
    Staff Writer

    RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

    Chile Supports Morocco’s Autonomy Plan
    Highlights on Morocco

    Chile Supports Morocco’s Autonomy Plan

    David Fisher Biden Will Build on Trump’s Western Sahara Breakthrough
    Morocco

    David Fischer: Biden Will Build on Trump’s Western Sahara Breakthrough

    Chief Rabbi Pinto Opens 1st Jewish Kindergarten in Morocco
    Morocco

    Chief Rabbi Pinto Opens 1st Jewish Kindergarten in Morocco

    Economy

    Samir Bennis: Morocco Needs to End Language Barriers to Attract Investments

    Algeria to Repatriate Trapped Algerian Students From Morocco After Backlash
    Highlights on Morocco

    Algeria to Repatriate Trapped Algerian Students From Morocco After Backlash

    Moroccan NGO to Collaborate With US Against Antisemitism, Anti-Zionism
    Morocco

    Moroccan NGO to Collaborate With US Against Antisemitism, Anti-Zionism

    MOST WATCHED VIDEOS
    Polisario Supporters Storm Moroccan Consulate General in Valencia

    Polisario Supporters Storm Moroccan Consulate General in Valencia

    Tamba François Koundouno - Nov 15, 2020
    Rania Sara Moroccan sisters the Voice Kids France

    The Voice Kids: French-Moroccan Sisters Amaze Judges to Reach Finals

    Diaspora Oct 4, 2020
    Video Shows Children Witnessing, Surviving Beirut Explosion

    Video Shows Children Witnessing, Surviving Beirut Explosion

    News Aug 5, 2020
    Beirut Explosion Leaves Royal Air Maroc Agency in Ruins

    Video: Beirut Explosion Leaves Royal Air Maroc Agency in Ruins

    International Aug 5, 2020
    ‘Morocco’s Warrior Women’ The Inspirational Riders Taking on Fantasia

    ‘Morocco’s Warrior Women’: The Inspirational Riders Taking on Fantasia

    Culture Jul 29, 2020
    MOST READ

    LIFESTYLE UPDATES

    Documentaries’ allure lies in narratives of unfiltered real events that might reveal shocking and unsettling truths.
    Book and Movie Reviews Jan 17, 2021

    Six Shocking and Unsettling Documentaries You Must Watch

    “Reflet” Exhibition Promoting Art in Morocco Amid COVID-19
    Casablanca Jan 17, 2021

    “Reflet” Exhibition Promoting Art in Morocco Amid COVID-19

    Amazigh Identity and Morocco’s Multicultural Challenge
    Culture Jan 17, 2021

    Amazigh Identity and Morocco’s Multicultural Challenge

    EXPERIENCES

    • Culture Morocco’s Red City: Touristic Places in Marrakech You Must Visit Morocco’s Red City: Touristic Places in Marrakech You Must Visit
    • Experiences California to Morocco: A Student’s COVID-19 Diary of Self-Discovery California to Morocco: A Student’s COVID-19 Diary of Self-Discovery
    • Experiences Travel in Morocco: Exploring Tinmel Mosque, a Hidden Gem Travel in Morocco: Exploring Tinmel Mosque, a Hidden Gem

    MOST READ

    MOST READ OPINIONS
    [getmostpop category=11 range="last30days"]

    Latest Articles

    Chile Supports Morocco’s Autonomy Plan

    David Fischer: Biden Will Build on Trump’s Western Sahara Breakthrough

    Chief Rabbi Pinto Opens 1st Jewish Kindergarten in Morocco

    Samir Bennis: Morocco Needs to End Language Barriers to Attract Investments

    Algeria to Repatriate Trapped Algerian Students From Morocco After Backlash

    Newsletter

    Invalid email address
    You can unsubscribe at any time.
    Thanks for subscribing! Please check your email for further instructions.
    Morocco World News

    About us

    Morocco World News: Championing Free Speech and Thoughtful Debate Through Journalistic Excellence.

    Morocco World News is dedicated to bringing the news of Morocco and the MENA region to a wide audience without bias or a political agenda.

    Contact us: [email protected]

    DMCA.com Protection Status

    Useful Links

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Contribute
    • Correspondents
    • Editorial Board
    We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
    Cookie settingsACCEPT
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled

    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

    Non-necessary

    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.