By Alissa de Carbonnel
By Alissa de Carbonnel
Moscow, June 5, 2012
Police detained some 20 activists protesting on Tuesday outside Russia’s parliament where deputies debated a Kremlin-backed bill to hike fines for violations during rallies, a proposal the opposition says is aimed at smothering dissent.
The controversial bill proposed by the ruling United Russia party following the biggest protests President Vladimir Putin’s 12-year-rule is all but guaranteed to be passed this week by the State Duma lower house, where United Russia holds a majority.
It would dramatically raise maximum fines to 1 million roubles ($30,000) for organizers and 300,000 roubles ($9,000) for citizens participating in demonstrations at which public order or city rules are deemed to have been violated.
In an unusually tense debate in the Duma, long a rubber-stamp body for the Kremlin, opposition lawmakers proposed more than 350 amendments to mark their disapproval and delay a bill they say is being fast-tracked by the Kremlin to be adopted before a planned mass protest in the capital on June 12.
“This is a monstrous bill which will essentially ban people from protesting,” Sergei Mitrokhin, an opposition leader whose Yabloko party has no seats in parliament, said outside the Duma. Moments later, he was roughly detained with other activists, many wearing the white-ribbon symbol of the anti-Putin movement.
Putin, who largely ignored a wave of winter protest that weakened his grip on his return to the presidency, signaled support for the bill in remarks at a summit with European Union leaders on Monday.
In a sign he would brook no Western criticism on human rights or democracy, the 59-year-old former KGB officer defended toughening rules governing protests as being in line with European norms.
Following fierce criticism by opposition lawmakers, some of the most controversial proposals, such as fines for Internet users who spread the word about rallies, were dropped.
But Kremlin critics say the proposed law remains draconian. It still stipulates fines for “public calls” to attend a rally, if later any of the attendees violate order, and a 30,000-rouble ($900) fine for participants of unauthorized rallies.
FREE ASSEMBLY FEARS
In addition to increasing fines from the current maximum of 5,000 roubles ($150), the law would prohibit demonstrators from covering their faces and carrying weapons, including rocks or paving stones.
Opposition leaders and rights activists, including the U.S.-based group Human Rights Watch, say the law violates the 31st article of Russia’s constitution on the right to free assembly.
“Today the 31st Article is disappearing from the Russian Constitution,” Gennady Gudkov, a Duma deputy with the opposition Just Russia party, told Reuters.
“The government’s priority is the suppression of dissent… criticism of the authorities will become the country’s chief crime.”
Taking the podium in the Duma session on Tuesday, Gudkov said the bill reflected the Kremlin’s “fear of the people.”
“This is a draconian law … it is the path toward civil war, it is the path toward massive repression and we all know how that ends: in blood, poverty and revolution,” Gudkov said.
Moscow city rules already require a permit for gatherings and police often use force to break up unsanctioned protests. Activists fear the law will be abused by police seeking legal cover to crack down on demonstrators.
The Kremlin’s human rights adviser said he would urge Putin to veto the bill when it was initially proposed last month, unless it was rewritten.
On the eve of the Duma debate, the human rights council’s chair Mikhail Fedotov said in an open letter that the law goes against Russia’s constitution.
Police largely left crowds alone during the wave of winter protests that at their height drew 100,000 people into Moscow’s streets over suspicions of fraud in favor of United Russia in December parliamentary polls.
But riot police have been tougher lately, beating protesters at a rally on the eve of Putin’s inauguration, detaining activists wearing white ribbons at a Moscow cafe and breaking up attempted round-the-clock protests.